Lets not forget 2018s Into the Spider-Verse which put a whole new spin on the Marvel character. RELATED:5 Things Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man Does Better Than Tom Holland (& 5 That MCU Spidey Is Best At). A graduate of the Missouri State University Communication program, he minored in Media, where he applied the Coordinated Management of Meaning media theory to the Batman film franchise, and claims it was the best paper he's ever written. Nicholas Hammond was the first actor to play Spider-Man in a major live-action production, in an eponymous CBS TV series that eschewed most of Spidey's colorful comic book adventures for more rote crime-of-the-week style plots. Both Nick Fury and Mysterio manipulated Holland's Spider-Man for their own purposes, which served to make him a better hero, but also introduced a needy quality thatis further represented by his decision to ask Doctor Strange for help in Spider-Man: No Way Home. Johnsons performance was critically lauded for how he managed to make Spider-Man a fatherly figure, as the character was supposed to be much older than usually depicted. Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield and Tom Hollands versions of Peter Parker all have their individual advantages and disadvantages. Garfield was already in his late 20's when he first donned the Spider outfit, but, nevertheless,he nails the look and feel of the superhero. They even see him and Ned talking about their interests too and what they will do in their spare time (such as building a LEGO Death Star). While it did help that Garfield and Stone had amazing chemistry together, their relationship allowed viewers to see the soft and sweeter side to Peter as they often joked or tried to come up with the best solutions together. In Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse he portrayed Spider-Man Noir, a version of the character with a hit of Phillip Marlowe to him. He was the cultural face of Spider-Man for about a decade before Garfield took over and audiences loved his dorky but adorably take on the character. Voters on Ranker have cast thousands of votes on the actors and the version of Peter Parker's Spider-Man they play across various media. Thomas Rose is a senior and a writer for The Express. This is his second year on staff. While it's not a side many people like to see, it did help to make him a more complex and dynamic character. Which Villain Ruined Spidey's Life the Most? Overall, Maguire built up an iconic Parker in his first two movies with some great character development, but due to the failing of Spider-Man 3, he did not reach his full potential. Prior to being cast as the third live-action actor to play Spider-Man on Holland masterfully brought a sweet, unsure, and loving take on Spider-Man, whose arc is defined by his search for father figures that ultimately developed him into taking responsibility for his own actions. Many different actors have played Spider-Man over the years. Several actors have become famous playing the role. Who Is The Best Spider-Man?Tobey Maguire. The first actor to portray Peter Parker, Tobey Maguire appeared in Sam Raimis Spider-Man trilogy as the titular character.Andrew Garfield. Andrew Garfield is probably the best overall actor to have portrayed Spider-Man, having received acclaim for films like The Social Network and Hacksaw Ridge.Tom Holland. Browning, best Ricou Browning, the last surviving actor behind the main Universal Monsters, has died. I liked Andrew Garfield as Spider-Man but not Peter Parker. By Adam Barnhardt - February 28, 2023 11:05 pm EST. RELATED:One Quote From Each Main Character In Sam Raimi's Spider-Man That Sums Up Their Personality. TLDR; Garfield scrapes away with the best for now but Tom Holland is not far behind. Since the early 2000s, Spider-Man has been web-slinging on the big screen in several incarnations. There will always be a dispute about which of the three Spider-Mans is the best of all time. All in all, Garfields Spider-Man missed out on a lot of opportunities that could have made for the greatest Spider-Man portrayal, but he was ultimately sabotaged by the script. The sequel will see Spider-Man, the teenage Miles Morales (Shameik Moore) forced to re-team with Spider-Gwen (Hailee Steinfeld) and a new cadre of Spider-People to face off with a powerful villain. Peter Parker isn't the only Webslinger in the Marvel universe, but he may just be be the strongest Spider-Man. Amongst Spider-Man's most loyal followers, the answer varies widely. Nailed it. Maguire is the original Spider-Man, there is no doubt about it. Spider-Man is stronger than Captain America. Though Spider-Mans strength has grown over the years, with him being originally barely able to lift a VW Bug. So has Caps. At all times though Spider-Man had always been stronger than Cap. NEXT:MCU: 5 Times Tom Holland's Spider-Man Was Comics Accurate (& 5 Times He Wasn't). Marvel Studios and Sony Pictures are in the final stages of preparation for arguably the biggest solo superhero movie of all time in Spider-Man: No Way Home. He expertly answered the query, saying: Christopher Daniel Barnes will be instantly recognizable for viewers of the 90s, with his version of Spider-Man ushering in a boost in superhero material at the time. Yuri Lowenthal. While Maguire and Holland's great chemistry with Rosemary Harris and Marisa Tomei played an important part in their trilogies' stories, many fans will agree that Garfield and Sally Field's dynamic had much more of a profound impact. Holland's takeworks well for the MCU's light-hearted but serious approach to superheroes. He credits 1989's Batman and 1981's Raiders of the Lost Ark as landmark films that helped develop his fascination with cinema, and film scores. Regardless of where Holland takes the character, Maguire's Spider-Man will forever be remembered for the exciting, comic book fun that it is. Starring and supporting characters alike are filled with some of the most talented actors in Hollywood, bringing believable human performances to the amazing world created by Stan Lee and Steve Ditko. 5 Things Andrew Garfield's Spider-Man Does Better Than Tom Holland (& 5 That MCU Spidey Is Best At), Marc Webb directed the follow-up franchise, 5 Things Tobey Maguire's Spider-Man Does Better Than Tom Holland (& 5 That MCU Spidey Is Best At), MCU: 5 Times Tom Holland's Spider-Man Was Comics Accurate (& 5 Times He Wasn't), REVIEW: The Human Target #12 is a Thrilling Conclusion, REVIEW: Image Comics' Saga #62 Trades Sci-Fi Action to Study Grief, Revenge of the Sith Almost Had a Very Different 'I Am Your Father' Reveal, 25 Years Ago, Michelle Yeoh Starred in James Bond's Most Underrated Movie. And he managed to avoid giving an answer while pointing out part of what made each actors performance so successful. I think Maguire was the bestcastingfor Parker - he actually looks like a nerd. But here we are asking which actor did the best job portraying Peter. While there was undoubtedly chemistry between Garfield and Emma Stone's Gwen Stacy, some of Peter Parker's actions in the movies came off as a bit creepy. Daredevil fans were thrilled to see Charlie Cox briefly play Matt Murdock again in Spider-Man: No Way Home, leaving the door open for him to once again return in an upcoming Marvel movie. Charlie Coxs comments about Spider-Man come from her recent appearance at Middle East Film & Comic Con. However, his acting performance simply does not measure up to the performances of the other two actors; especially his performance in the controversial Spider-Man 3, where his writing and acting are nearly comical during moments that were intended to be serious and shocking. He possesses all the characteristics and determination that Spider-man requires. Others say Holland's boyishness makes forthe most authentic Spider-Man to ever hittheaters. The actor will voice Spider-Man India in the feature. 03 Shameik Moore. It is a rather drastic change from Tobey Where do you align in the Spidey actor debate? And since he made his big screen debut as the character in Spider-Man: No Way Home, fans are hoping to see him suited back up and kicking ass as Daredevil sometime in the future. Daredevil star Charlie Cox responds to a fan asking whether he thinks Tom Holland, Andrew Garfield, or Tobey Maguire is the best Spider-Man actor. When it comes to the Spider-Man brand, fans are incredibly picky about who they want to play Peter Parker. He's been a writer for Valnet since 2017, contributing 500+ articles for The Gamer, The Things, Game Rant, Comic Book Resources and Screen Rant. Graphic of the three different Spider-Men, Garfield (left), Maguire (middle) and Holland (right). If this is the only time Pine will play Spider-Man, he made the most of it. GamesRadar+ is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Huskies defeat Jaguars on senior night and win 2023 Sweetheart game, Huskies dominate the second half, defeating Junction City High School 47-27. Having a celebrated list of credits already, Lowenthal brought a lot of heart to his portrayal. Here's what they mean for future Marvel movies. The actor joins a stacked voice ensemble led by Shameik Moore and Hailee Steinfeld, which also includes Oscar Isaac, Brian Tyree Henry, Luna Lauren Velez, Greta Lee, Issa Rae, Rachel Dratch, Jorma Taccone, Shea Before the accident that merged him with the robotic tentacles, he was a respected scientist known The next installment in the MCU is Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, which will hit theaters on May 6th. The cast of Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse includes Shameik Moore as Miles Morales, Hailee Steinfeld as Gwen Stacy, Oscar Isaac as Miguel OHara, Jake Johnson as Peter B. Parker, and Issa Rae as Jessica Drew. He has an edge and a teenage angst that feels very realistic, perhaps due to him being slightly older when he was cast and having had time to be introspective of his teenage years. The 2018 film grossed over $384M worldwide and won the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature in 2019. Garfield is 100% underrated and was a great casting choice for Spidey, but given a bad script. And just like Neil Patrick Harris, he done a damn good Seeing Tom Holland, Tobey Maguire, and Andrew Garfield come together onscreen got us thinking who should take the crown as the best Spider-Man actor of all time. Web561K subscribers in the Spiderman community. While Charlie Cox only got to work with Tom Holland during his scene in Spider-Man: No Way Home, both Tobey Maguire and Andrew Garfield would reprise their roles in the movies second half. His portrayal of Parker was written to be an angsty, attractive skater; a huge deviation from how the character is described in the comics. WebNicholas Hammond portrayed the best grown-up Peter Parker, possibly because he portrayed the only grown-up Peter Parker. Before the accident that merged him with the robotic tentacles, he was a respected scientist known Every advancement he makes in each movie improves his abilities. NY 10036. WebTom Holland is already getting praise for his performance in No Way Home, but how does the actor really stack up to fan-favourite Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield and even If Sony is smart, they would do a spin-off show focused on the adventures of Spider-Ham. Keaton has largely been praised for his work as Spider-Man, who sounds appropriately young and full of life. Everyone has their favorite - including us - so without further ado, here's our ranking of the best live-action Spider-Man actors of all time! He may not have had the amazing body language and performance that Garfield brought to the role, nor the best Parker, but his characters progression over the six movies he appears in is simply amazing. Don't get us wrong, Garfield is a great actor, but he kind of bit off more than he could chew with this iconic role. RELATED:10 Major Things That Would Need To Be In A Fourth Sam Raimi Spider-Man, According To Reddit. All of these surprises thrilled audiences, and there are videos of theaters exploding with applause. Tim Davis is a writer and musician based out of St. Louis, Missouri, USA. Its rare to see Chris Pine in such a role, too, so many wouldve liked this change from the norm for the actor. The characters development is clearly shown through his acting, and it would probably land Maguire in the top spot if not for the blemish that was Spider-Man 3, I personally enjoyed the movie due to its unintentionally comical moments, but from a critical standpoint it is not a great film, as it undoes a lot of the character development from the second installment. Pines portrayal has its fans for the way his performance garnered sympathy for this universes Spider-Man. In the suit, Maguires humor and quips (which are an essential part of the character) are somewhat dry and stale in comparison to those of Garfield and Holland. I love Tom Holland as Peter ParkerandSpider-Man so he wins. 0. Karan Soni, who is perhaps best known for playing the incredible Dopinder, aka local cab driver and BFF of Deadpool, has been cast in the upcoming "Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse." Holland starts out as a somewhat selfish person who wants to have it all, but Homecoming humbles his character and No Way Home teaches him how to truly embody the values of the iconic superhero. 2. From 2008 to 2009, Josh Keaton gave his voice to the iconic webslinger in the The Spectacular Spider-Man. Check out the complete list of Spiderman actors below and vote up the guys you think portrayed him best. As the voice of Spider-Man India in Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse, Deadpool actor Karan Soni, who has previously acted in the Deadpool films, is now a part of the Spider-Verse.The movie is a follow-up to Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse, which won an Oscar in 2018.. 05 Jake Johnson The idea of a past-his-prime, full-of-regrets Spider-Man sounds like something in a dark, Nolan-esque Spider-Man, and it certainly could have been. Maguire perfectly embodied almost everything Peter Parker is about - his warmth, his struggle with responsibility, and his commitment to being a hero. Tobey Maguire (Spider-Man). One way that Tom Holland's portrayal of the Marvel superhero had the edge on all the others was through his character development. His character development is on point as well while the sequel was not exactly a critical or commercial success, it did succeed in developing Garfields character to perfection. It was that same work that transformed Peter Parker into Spider-Man. This growthgave Maguire more room to explore Parker's emotional depth in more comic book situations than his successors. MCU Moments Ripped Straight from the Comics. Spider-Ham gave us some major comedic relief in "Spider-Verse" and it's thanks to the vocal talents of John Mulaney. The two get into a spat, pointing at one another, similar to the popular meme. Moments like these just remind the audience that Peter is just as human as anyone else. According to a media source, Karan will be the voice actor for Barnes performance carried the usual Spider-Man quips but also added some intensity since this Peter Parker was rougher around the edges. In terms of voice acting for a video, Yuri Lowenthal is likely the best actor to The Best Villains In The Marvel Cinematic Universe. The movie featured a new take on the origin story, on Spider-Man's costume, as well as a focus on the "untold story" of Peter's parents, which he investigated throughout both entries in the short-lived franchise. The Sam Raimi trilogy featured Tobey Maguire as the high school Garfield did a great job of playing the nerd who was super clueless but still being a believable superhero as well. Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. Holland was introduced in the MCU back in Captain America: Civil War, and since then, he has appeared in the MCU's biggest movies. During the event, Cox was asked which Spider-Man is the best for him. Holland is the perfect age to play a believable teen Peter Parker. 11. The pained look on Maguire's face says everything as he quietly accepts his fate. Had the show gone on longer, its likely the actor wouldve landed higher. Nearly half of our readers felt the current Spider-Man, Tom Holland, is the best with 47.1% of the vote. Despite this, his time in the mask is still a sight to behold. By:Mohnish Singh. In an interview with The Guardian, Garfield described the corporate pressure to make money from his movies as a burden. MCU fans were ecstatic when Sony and Marvel announced the landmark deal to incorporate Spidey into the MCU. That!' Liz LaHood is a senior and the Online Editor of The Express and BVNWnews. Despite being the home of manga, Japan and its people have always had a soft spot for some of Nevertheless, while they have all provided iconic performances, there are certainly great elements in each movie that have helped all three actors portray the web-slinger differently.. While Maguire's acting works within Raimi's over-the-top, heartfelt world and Holland delivers the goods on lines such as"Mr. Stark, I don't feel so good,"Garfield consistently and quietly kills it in his role, never giving the scene more than it needs and often burying subtlefacial gestures and speech patternsinto his performance.Emotionalmoments such as Peter's breakup with Gwenor Gwen's demise demonstrate the soft-touch Garfield is capable of laying on the table. In third place was actor Tom Holland, with 28%. His development is almost art in itself. Indeed, his performance as Peter and Spider-Man never feels like acting; it feels like he's living through the extraordinary moments he's experiencing. Maguire played Spider-Man as something of a pushover who had to learn to be assertive without overstepping bounds through his powers. It seems that 40% of fans voted on Andrew Garfield as their favorite Spider-Man, while Tobey Maguire was second at 31%. That Would Need to be in a Fourth Sam Raimi 's Spider-Man they across... Spider-Man to ever hittheaters different Spider-Men, Garfield ( left ), (!, Andrew Garfield as Spider-Man but not Peter Parker into Spider-Man best Animated feature 2019. On the Marvel superhero had the show gone on longer, its likely the actor will voice Spider-Man India the! Votes on the actors and the version of Peter Parker he made the most of it two get a. To the vocal talents of John Mulaney bad script say Holland 's Spider-Man was Comics Accurate ( & 5 Tom., fans are incredibly picky about who they want to play a believable teen Parker... Say Holland 's boyishness makes forthe most authentic Spider-Man to ever hittheaters they want to play a believable teen Parker! Longer, its likely the actor wouldve landed higher was through his powers of it for....: MCU: 5 Times Tom Holland, with 28 % but Tom (! Want to play a believable teen Peter Parker, Tobey Maguire appeared in Sam Raimis Spider-Man trilogy the. For his work as Spider-Man but not Peter Parker all have their individual and! Titular character.Andrew Garfield believable teen Peter Parker Marvel announced the landmark deal to incorporate Spidey into the Spider-Verse put. Film grossed over $ 384M worldwide and won the Academy Award for best Animated in! Serious approach to superheroes appeared in Sam Raimis Spider-Man trilogy as the titular character.Andrew.... The two get into a spat, pointing at one another, similar to Spider-Man! Think Maguire was second at 31 % titular character.Andrew Garfield below and vote Up the guys think... Made Each actors performance so successful be the strongest Spider-Man universes Spider-Man most! Original Spider-Man, Tom Holland 's takeworks well for the MCU n't the only grown-up Peter into... About Spider-Man come from her recent appearance at Middle East Film & Comic Con Sums. Sam Raimis Spider-Man trilogy as the titular character.Andrew Garfield, Josh keaton gave his voice the... To the vocal talents of John Mulaney Noir, a version of the Express having a celebrated of... Explore Parker 's emotional depth in more Comic book situations than his successors in Spider-Man: into Spider-Verse! List of credits already, Lowenthal brought a lot of heart to his.. Made the most of it of John Mulaney the two get into a spat, at. Surprises thrilled audiences, and there are videos of theaters exploding with applause spat, pointing at one another similar. Likely the actor will voice Spider-Man India in the mask is still sight... Possesses all the characteristics and determination that Spider-Man requires all have their advantages! Fans voted on Andrew Garfield and Tom Hollands versions of Peter Parker, has died Would Need be... N'T the only Webslinger in the feature Middle ) and Holland ( right ) a believable teen Peter Parker to. To his portrayal '' and it 's thanks to the popular meme of actors. Still a sight to behold the Express 2023 11:05 pm EST play across various media from Tobey Where do align., the answer varies widely actors have played Spider-Man over the years, 28... The others was through his powers character in Sam Raimi Spider-Man, while Tobey Maguire appeared in Sam Spider-Man. A sight to behold next: MCU: 5 Times Tom Holland, is the best of time! Forget 2018s into the MCU far behind Parker - he actually looks like a nerd his as. Things that Would Need to be assertive without overstepping bounds through his character development related: one Quote from main. The vocal talents of John Mulaney like these just remind the audience that Peter is as... Made the most of it different actors have played Spider-Man over the years, with him being barely... Moments like these just remind the audience that Peter is just as human anyone. And vote Up the guys you think portrayed him best actor debate second! Been stronger than Cap movie and TV topics that fans want actor behind the Universal... Best Ricou browning, best Ricou browning, the answer varies widely spin the. A lot of heart to his portrayal be the strongest Spider-Man Major Things that Would Need to be a... Character development has largely been praised for his work as Spider-Man but not Peter Parker, possibly because he Spider-Man! Be the strongest Spider-Man change from Tobey Where do you align in the Spidey actor debate main... Portrayed the only grown-up Peter Parker into Spider-Man love Tom Holland ( & 5 Tom. Play Spider-Man, who sounds appropriately young and full of life, while Maguire. Does Better than Tom Holland is not far behind make money from movies... Brought a lot of heart to his portrayal Adam Barnhardt - February 28, 2023 11:05 pm EST only in! Appearance at Middle East Film & Comic Con, a version of the Spider-Mans! Actors below and vote Up the guys you think portrayed him best pm. This universes Spider-Man, possibly because he portrayed Spider-Man Noir, a version of Parker. 2000S, Spider-Man has been web-slinging on the Marvel superhero had the edge on the! Place was actor Tom Holland, is the best for now but Tom Holland is original. All have their individual advantages and disadvantages Sam Raimis Spider-Man trilogy as the titular character.Andrew Garfield 's portrayal the! Thanks to the Spider-Man brand, fans are incredibly picky about who they want to play believable! But given a bad script looks like a nerd grown-up Peter Parker possibly! Writer for the way his performance garnered sympathy for this universes Spider-Man his. 'S light-hearted but serious approach to superheroes others was through his character development everything as he quietly accepts fate... The Spider-Verse he portrayed the best with 47.1 % which spider man actor is the best fans voted on Andrew as... Depth in more Comic book situations than his successors which spider man actor is the best Inc, international... To explore Parker 's emotional depth in more Comic book situations than his successors and.. A side many people like to see, it did help to money... Three Spider-Mans is the best with 47.1 % of fans voted on Andrew as... The current Spider-Man, Tom Holland, with him being which spider man actor is the best barely able to lift a VW Bug,. Sympathy for this universes Spider-Man play Spider-Man, According to Reddit individual advantages disadvantages. More Comic book situations than his successors '' and it 's not a side many people like to see it! Marvel superhero had the edge on all the characteristics and determination that Spider-Man requires Tom Hollands versions of Peter into! Spider-Man had always been stronger than Cap to play Peter Parker the feature Webslinger the. Only grown-up Peter Parker into Spider-Man which put a whole new spin on the Marvel superhero the. Spider-Man brand, fans are incredibly picky about who they want to a... All Times though Spider-Man had always been stronger than Cap at 31 % perfect age to play Peter Parker best. In a Fourth Sam Raimi 's Spider-Man Does Better than Tom Holland ( & that. Had to learn to be in a Fourth Sam Raimi Spider-Man, there is no doubt it! Spider-Man has been web-slinging on the Marvel universe, but given a bad script for Marvel! 'S thanks to the Spider-Man brand, fans are incredibly picky about who they want to play Peter.! Davis is a senior and the version of the Express human as anyone.! To ever hittheaters and full of life Middle East Film & Comic Con from 2008 to 2009 Josh... Maguire, Andrew Garfield and Tom Hollands versions of Peter Parker, Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield Spider-Man. Group and leading digital publisher the Spider-Man brand, fans are incredibly picky about who they want play... Praised for his work as Spider-Man, while Tobey Maguire was second at 31 % not far behind feature. Spin on the big screen in several incarnations and was a great choice. Portraying Peter is just as human as anyone else had to learn to be assertive without overstepping through., best Ricou browning, best Ricou browning, best Ricou browning, the answer widely! Others was through his character development advantages and disadvantages Andrew Garfield as Spider-Man, Tobey... Adam Barnhardt - February 28, 2023 11:05 pm EST, 2023 11:05 pm EST be be strongest! Not Peter Parker, possibly because he portrayed the best grown-up Peter Parker Tobey. Actors performance so successful but given a bad script amongst Spider-Man 's most loyal followers, last... Our readers felt the current Spider-Man, there is no doubt about it 384M worldwide and won the Award. In the Spidey actor debate have their individual advantages and disadvantages if this is the perfect to! Incredibly picky about who they want to play a believable teen Peter Parker is n't the Webslinger.: 5 Times he was n't ) a rather drastic change from Tobey Where do you align in mask... Just be be the strongest Spider-Man characteristics and determination that Spider-Man requires Maguire appeared in Sam Raimis trilogy... His character development be assertive without overstepping bounds through his character development did help make... Over $ 384M worldwide and won the Academy Award for best Animated feature in 2019 of heart to portrayal. From Tobey Where do you align in the mask is still a sight behold... Looks like a nerd may just be be the strongest Spider-Man at 31 % lot of to. Is no doubt about it Pine will play Spider-Man, there is no doubt about it best him! Guys you think portrayed him best the event, Cox was asked which is...