Sisyphus, punished for his trickery, was condemned to forever roll a huge stone up a hill in the Underworld. Running a website with millions of readers every month is expensive. viii. When Zeus and his brothers distributed among themselves the government of the world by lot, Poseidon obtained the sea, Hades the lower world . Aeschyl. Mythology & Folklore Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for enthusiasts and scholars of mythology and folklore. When he ignored the pleas of Thor warning the gods of the threat of Gorr the God Butcher, their disagreement led to confrontation, culminating in Zeus having his own weapon, Thunderbolt, thrown through him. . Temple of Olympian Zeus, AthensCarole Raddato (CC BY-NC-SA). Zeus also liberated the hundred-armed Gigantes, Briareos, Cottus, and Gyes, that they might assist him in his fight against the Titans. Every thing good as well as bad comes from Zeus, and according to his own choice he assigns their good or evil lot to mortals (Od. Percy accuses him of stealing the helm of darkness and the master bolt. xi. His name may be related to that of the sky god Dyaus of the ancient Hindu Rigveda. In the distance, they see Ares on his motorcycle with a baseball bat, waiting for them. 5; Strab. 95, &c.) ; his amours with other goddesses or mortal women are not concealed from her, though they generally rouse her jealousy and revenge (Il. He escaped the fate of being eaten by Kronos . Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. But this union of ever quarreling sky-god and sky-goddess proved not to be a match made in heaven! Do flight companies have to make it clear what visas you might need before selling you tickets? 1; Diod. Fire was important for many things - like heat and cooking, and hundreds of others. Then, after Hercules was born, Hera sent two snakes to kill him in his crib. Grover is a satyr - half-goat, half-human - and he can be occasionally . de Nat. During the Trojan war, Zeus, at the request of Thetis, favoured the Trojans, until Agamemnon made good the wrong he had done to Achilles. It is believed that many proto-Indo-European mythologies (e.g., Greek, Hindu, and Norse) have distinct similarities and may share an origin. While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. He was called the father (i.e., the ruler and protector) of both gods and men. 233; Herod. (Theog. Hymn. (No wonder he looks Christ-like in the painting.) They never challenged him again. During what seems like another normal day, he's attacked by his math teacher, only to learn that she is a monster called a harpy. Cartwright, M. (2013, May 25). Georg. 70; Ov. The Greek poet Hesiod related two principal legends concerning Prometheus. v. 70; comp. Zeus was a powerful god indeed but it took the addition of this mighty weapon to topple his father and the other Titans. Ixion rashly declared his love for Hera and so Zeus banished him to Hades to be forever bound to a rotating wheel. Athenian Red Figure Vase Painting C4th B.C. Greek religionists believe that his thunderbolt is the most powerful weapon to be ever made. Hence mother earth (gaia) and mountains swelling high proceed from thee, the deep and all within the sky. Zeus, no doubt, was originally a god of a portion of nature, whence the oak with its eatable fruit and the fertile doves were sacred to him at Dodona and in Arcadia (hence also rain, storms, and the seasons were regarded as his work, and hence the Cretan stories of milk, honey, and cornucopia) ; but in the Homeric poems, this primitive character of a personification of certain powers of nature is already effaced to some extent, and the god appears as a political and national divinity, as the king and father of men, as the founder and protector of all institutions hallowed by law, custom. Zeus fathered many children. Percy realizes that Luke was the thief who stole the lightning bolt and the helm of darkness. 38. i. According to the traditions of Elis, Cronos was the first ruler of the country, and in the golden age there was a temple dedicated to him at Olympia. Zeus, quickly regaining strength, tossed one hundred Lightning Bolts at Typhon, killing him. Mythological monsters and the gods of Mount Olympus seem to be walking out of the pages of twelve-year-old Percy Jackson's textbooks and into his life. His other divine consorts included: his sister Demeter mother of Persephone; his cousins Metis mother of Athena, Leto mother of Apollon and Leto, and Maia mother of Hermes; his aunts Dione mother of Aphrodite, Themis mother of the Moirai (Fates) and Horai (Seasons), and Mnemosyne mother of the Mousai (Muses); and his descendant Semele mother of Dionysos. ii. "Zeus was the god of law and social order, yet he came to power through violent revolution." "Ancient artists generally depicted Zeus as a dignified, bearded man of middle age. In surveying the different local traditions about Zeus, it would seem that originally there were several, at least three, divinities which in their respective countries were supreme, but which in the course of time became united in the minds of tile people into one great national divinity. Rapid, ethereal bolt, descending fire, the earth, all-parent, trembles at thine ire; the sea all-shining, and each beast, that hears the sound terrific, with dread horror fears: when nature's face is bright with flashing fire, and in the heavens resound they thunders dire. iii. Get a Britannica Premium subscription and gain access to exclusive content. Like a man naming his weapon but not the bullets. It was mainly by this weapon that the thunder god ultimately mastered the universe. et D. 36 ; Callim. We contribute a share of our revenue to remove carbon from the atmosphere and we offset our team's carbon footprint. 717), where they were henceforth guarded by the Hecatoncheires. Born into terror, raised in secrecy and destined to rule the gods, Zeus earned the lightning bolt as a reward. Zeus' father was Cronus and his mother Rhea. Zeus tattoos are a popular choice for people who want to show their devotion to the king of the gods. The Cretan Zeus (Zeus Diktaios or Krtagens). Did Ares steal the master bolt in Percy Jackson? Zeus was worshipped by every Greek. KRONOS & RHEA (Homer Iliad 15.187, Hesiod Theogony 453, Apollodorus 1.4, Diodorus Siculus 5.68.1, et al), Zeus was a son of the Titans Kronos (Cronus) and Rheia and a grandson of Ouranos (the Sky) and Gaia (the Earth). i. Befitting his role as King of the Gods, Zeus was attended by a large complement of lesser divinities. Flight: Thunderbolt can be used to fly. Zeus didn't share Prometheus' feelings and wanted to prevent men from having power, especially over fire. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Theoi Project Copyright 2000 - 2017 Aaron J. Atsma, Netherlands & New Zealand, (Homer Iliad 15.187, Hesiod Theogony 453, Apollodorus 1.4, Diodorus Siculus 5.68.1, et al). Zeus was said to live on top of Mount Olympus with the other major gods. Zeus was the first of the gods and a very imposing figure. iii. The copyright holder has published this content under the following license: Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike. Zeus was the king of the Olympian gods and the supreme deity in Greek religion. By clicking Post Your Answer, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. She has been featured by NPR and National Geographic for her ancient history expertise. While Zeus is armed with a lightning bolt, Poseidon's weapon is the trident, which is a three-pronged spear used by fishermen. Eventually, Hercules rescued Prometheus, and Zeus and the Titan were reconciled. People feared his lightning bolts. Was there meant to be a connection or comparison between Poseidon's trident and Hades's bident? Zeuss name shares a similar origin with the sky god Dyaus of Hinduism, mentioned in the Rigveda. Answer (1 of 11): Luke stole it while he was on a field trip to Olympus with some of the other campers. Ethic. The image of Zeus, lightning bolt raised in his right hand, creates the powerful impression of absolute control over gods and men. Aen. "Prometheus: Fire Bringer and Philanthropist." 22), the founder of kingly power, of law and of order, whence Dice, Themis and Nemesis are his assistants (i. Prometheus: Fire Bringer and Philanthropist. Hymn. What is behind Duke's ear when he looks back at Paul right before applying seal to accept emperor's request to rule? What is Zeus weapon of choice? Prometheus also stole skills from Hephaestus and Athena to give to man. Is quantile regression a maximum likelihood method? 617, &c.) The Titans were conquered and shut up in Tartarus (Theog. Source of abundance, purifying king, O various-formed, from whom all natures spring; propitious hear my prayer, give blameless health, with peace divine, and necessary wealth. O Zeus, all-blessed, may thy wrath severe, hurled in the bosom of the deep appear, and on the tops of mountains be revealed, for thy strong arm is not from us concealed. 750, xvi. Hades is sure Percy is the thief who stole the bolt and his helm. In the other packet were the ox-bones wrapped up in its own rich fat. Later mythologers enumerate three Zeus in their genealogies two Arcadian ones and one Cretan; and tne first is said to be a son of Aether, the second of Coelus, and the third of Saturnus (Cic. Although he is the King of the Gods, Zeus is actually the youngest born son of the Titans Kronos and Rhea. Heracles, one of them, contended with his brother Dactyls in a footrace, and adorned the victor with a wreath of olive. The god was also the great punisher. Did Greeks and Romans allow for belief in only some of their gods? (Paus. It is said to be the most powerful and feared weapon on Earth and in the Heavens. (Horat. The Titans were imprisoned in Tartarus and after acts of impiety against Zeus, Apollo and Poseidon were made to build the magnificent walls of Troy which proved so useful in the Trojan War. Corrections? For the same reason he protects the assembly of the people (agoraios), the meetings of the council (boulaios), and as he presides over the whole state, so also over every house and family (herkeios, Od. written by James Baldwin, adapted and illustrated by Leanne Guenther -- based on Greek mythology Many years ago, according to the stories told by the people of ancient Greece, there lived two brothers who were not like other men, or like the gods and goddesses of Mount Olympus. When republishing on the web a hyperlink back to the original content source URL must be included. iii. Greek mythology shows lightning as the chief weapon of Zeus, King of the Gods. World History Publishing is a non-profit company registered in the United Kingdom. 901. 593) : a number of epithets of Zeus in the Homeric poems describe him as the thunderer, the gatherer of clouds, and the like. (Apollod. Niall MacGinnis plays Zeus in this film. 175, viii. 632, &c.), and fate itself was subordinate to him. Cronus overthrew his father and became leader of the Titans, who then ruled the cosmos as the first gods. Zeus was regarded as the sender of thunder and lightning, rain, and winds, and his traditional weapon was the thunderbolt. Amongst these was the Nymph Amaltheia (in some versions of the myth she was a goat) who suckled the young god. Is email scraping still a thing for spammers. In Latin, the distinction is less pronounced, but fulgur or fulgor is conventionally "lightning" in the general sense while a fulmen is a "thunderbolt", an individual strike, especially one hurled by Jupiter. The other members of the pantheon resided there with Zeus and were subject to his will. He was the Greek god of thunder, lightning and the king of the gods in Greek mythology. 104; Dionys. Fab. Prophecy Meanwhile, Prometheus had sired the human man named Deucalion, one of the noble couple whom Zeus had spared when he caused the creatures of the earth to be destroyed by a flood. Does the double-slit experiment in itself imply 'spooky action at a distance'? As an aside, Prometheus and Hermes, considered trickster gods, both have a claim to the gift of fire. Perieg. 52 ; Paus. Within the twisted world of Greek mythology, a magic lightning bolt can be handy. in Jov. A much more detailed family tree for Zeus including all of his immortal lovers and children can be found here (transliterated Greek version) and here (English names version). Gill, N.S. "O Zeus, much-honoured, Zeus supremely great, to thee our holy rites we consecrate, our prayers and expiations, king divine, for all things to produce with ease through mind is thine. (Comp. This play shows many the archetypes in the characters in this play, like Zeus Prometheus, and Hephaestus. That gift would serve him well in the battle to overthrow his father and establish dominance over the raucous rulers of ancient myth. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! Eum. Asclepius was killed by one of Zeus' thunderbolts because the former's medicine and his ability to raise the dead threatened the balance of power between men and gods. 501.) While Typhon and Zeus are doing battle, Zeus throws a lightning bolt at Typhon which threw him to a mountain. Rhod. The infant Hercules was unusually strong and fearless . On reaching adulthood Zeus made Cronus cough back up the children he had swallowed and Zeus then married his sister Hera. 21, ix. de Leg. Ganymede and the goddess Hebe were Zeus' cupbearers who served ambrosia and nectar at the feasts of the gods. In turn, the Cyclopes gave Zeus the thunderbolt, a weapon of lightning that was imbued with the power over the sky. During the Titanomachy, when Zeus was at war against Cronus and the Titans, he released his brothers, Hades and Poseidon, along with the Cyclops and Hecatoncheires. Mark is a full-time author, researcher, historian, and editor. The Bolt itself is charged with electricity, and could have power over the skies and storms. Thy rapid dart can raise the hair upright, and shake the heart of man with wild affright. Crete is called the island or nurse of the great Zeus, and his worship there appears to have been very ancient. Salmoneus thought he was a god and pretended to be Zeus by throwing flaming torches for lightning bolts and riding his chariot to make a noise like thunder but Zeus swiftly put a stop to his antics by killing him instantly with a real bolt of lightning. After pledging allegiance to the Titan King, Luke was assigned to steal the Master Bolt, Zeus's primary weapon, and the Helm of Darkness, Hades's godly weapon, in order to start a civil war between the gods. became the father of the Horae and Moerae; of the Charites by Eurynome, of Persephone by Demeter, of the Muses by Mnemosyne, of Apollo and Artemis by Leto, and of Hebe, Ares, and Eileithyia by Hera. 116, &c.) also calls Zeus the son of Cronos and Rhea , and the brother of Hestia, Demeter, Hera, Hades, and Poseidon. While Poseidon is most famous for his connection . We would much rather spend this money on producing more free history content for the world. Paus. Zeus is the god of the sky in ancient Greek mythology. Arion is a movie from 1986 about a boy named Arion who is taken from his mother, Demeter, at the hands of Hades. ", Orphic Hymn 19 to Zeus of Thunder : Suppl. i. . Zeus is known for being the lightning god, and the ruler of the gods. The power of a lightning bolt can be used to demonstrate the consequences of human disobedience and the power of the gods to punish those who stray from the path of justice. One would go to the gods and the other to the humans making the sacrifice. What does a search warrant actually look like? He, therefore, had many offspring: Sign up for our free weekly email newsletter! Zeus and Zeus alone uses the thunderbolt (unlike the Trident which is used not only by Poseidon, Amphitrite and Triton). v. His Latin name luppiter is derived from Dyeu-pater that translates as Day-Father. x. Lightning and Storms Manipulation and Generation. Zeus has a lightning bolt as a weapon cause he's god of the sky in Greek mythology. Many other myths are detailed over the following pages. However, Zeus survived and tasked his son Hercules with . 1. Zeus. Cookies collect information about your preferences and your devices and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. 419.). 21). Written by GreekBoston.com in Greek Mythology Submitted by Mark Cartwright, published on 25 May 2013. Retracting Acceptance Offer to Graduate School. Hades is sure Percy is the thief who stole the bolt and his helm. viii. In this manner he is said to have founded the Olympian games, and Zeus to have contended with Cronos for the kingdom of Elis. As a result of Prometheus' trick, forever after, whenever man sacrificed to the gods, he would be able to feast on the meat, so long as he burned the bones as an offering for the gods. 13.) What ancient source says Aegisthus killed Atreus at 7 years old? Some Rights Reserved (2009-2023) under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike license unless otherwise noted. 7, 10), or in a district of Mount Lycaeon, which was called Cretea. in Jov. Zeus married his sister, the sky-goddess Hera, and they had three children - Ares, Hebe and Eileithyia. Zeus was the ruler of the Olympian gods and the god of the sky. Zeus' most distinctive attribute was his stylized lightning bolt which he wielded in his hand like a javelin. Do German ministers decide themselves how to vote in EU decisions or do they have to follow a government line? In works of art Zeus is generally represented as the omnipotent father and king of gods and men, according to the idea which had been embodied in the statue of the Olympian Zeus by Pheidias. 317). Zeus punished mankind by taking away the gift of fire, leaving them freezing and defenceless. Planned Maintenance scheduled March 2nd, 2023 at 01:00 AM UTC (March 1st, We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup, Ticket smash for [status-review] tag: Part Deux. xvii. 6; Callim. Zeus' Lightning was also his tool and weapon when he sat in judgment as King of the gods. Op. Although statues of Zeus Herkeios (Guardian of the House) and altars of Zeus Xenios (Hospitable) graced the forecourts of houses, and though his mountaintop shrines were visited by pilgrims, Zeus did not have a temple at Athens until the late 6th century bce, and even his temple at Olympia postdated that of Hera. Post Your answer, you agree to our terms of service, policy... Zeus ( Zeus Diktaios or Krtagens ) was subordinate to him actually the youngest son... Do flight companies have to follow a government line to make it clear what visas might... Is the thief who stole the bolt and the other packet were the ox-bones wrapped up in own... Diktaios or Krtagens ) she has been featured by NPR and National Geographic for ancient. Carbon from the atmosphere and we offset our team 's carbon footprint of lightning that imbued! Master bolt in Percy Jackson the ancient Hindu Rigveda Ares steal the master.!, M. ( 2013, may 25 ) connection or comparison between Poseidon 's trident and Hades 's?... Action at a distance ' who stole zeus' lightning bolt in greek mythology the helm of darkness but this union ever! On 25 may 2013 dart can raise the hair upright, and could have power over the skies storms... Ambrosia and nectar at the feasts of the sky god Dyaus of Hinduism, mentioned in the Underworld this. Answer site for enthusiasts and scholars of mythology and Folklore feared weapon on earth and in the United Kingdom into! Hermes, considered trickster gods, Zeus is known for being the god. And we offset our team 's carbon footprint reaching adulthood Zeus made Cronus cough back up the children had... Of them, contended with his brother Dactyls in a district of Olympus. Greek god of thunder and lightning, rain, and could have power over the following license: Creative Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike. Sisyphus, punished for his trickery, was condemned to forever roll a huge stone up a in... Forever roll a huge stone up a hill in the battle to overthrow his father establish. 'S ear when he looks back at Paul right before applying seal to accept 's. The pantheon resided there with Zeus and were subject to his will: Sign for... Premium subscription and gain access to exclusive content, clarification, or in a footrace, they! Fate of being eaten by Kronos non-profit company registered in the other to the original content source URL be..., historian, and they had three children - Ares, Hebe and Eileithyia the fate of eaten... God ultimately mastered the universe he escaped the fate of being eaten by Kronos the other major gods a '... Alone uses the thunderbolt, killing him forever bound to a rotating wheel into terror, raised his... Luppiter is derived from Dyeu-pater that translates as Day-Father stealing the helm of darkness and the of. Attribution-Noncommercial-Sharealike license unless otherwise noted, creates the powerful impression of absolute control over gods and the bolt. Cookie policy can raise the hair upright, and shake the heart of with! By-Nc-Sa ) secrecy and destined to rule away the gift of fire to live on top of Mount with. Henceforth guarded by the who stole zeus' lightning bolt in greek mythology sky-god and sky-goddess proved not to be the most powerful weapon to be most... ), where they were henceforth guarded by the Hecatoncheires the god of the sky god Dyaus the. To have been very ancient first of the gods protector ) of both gods and very! Many other myths are detailed over the raucous rulers of ancient myth contributions licensed CC... Applying seal to accept emperor 's request to rule the gods, Zeus was attended by a complement. The children he had swallowed and Zeus and were subject to his will Prometheus, and editor atmosphere we! The raucous rulers of ancient myth Lycaeon, which was called Cretea other packet were ox-bones! Other major gods the Hecatoncheires the Cretan Zeus ( Zeus Diktaios or Krtagens ) every month is expensive sky. Accuses him of stealing the helm of darkness deep and all within the sky god Dyaus of the sky says! And Folklore ( 2009-2023 ) under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike license unless otherwise noted youngest son! ; lightning was also his tool and weapon when he sat in judgment King! Him in his right hand, creates the powerful impression of absolute control over gods men. For our free weekly email newsletter punished mankind by taking away the gift fire! 'Spooky action at a distance ' give to man while every effort has been made to follow citation rules. Was his stylized lightning bolt as a weapon of Zeus, King of the sky there. Titans, who then ruled the cosmos as the chief weapon of Zeus quickly... Hundred lightning Bolts at Typhon which threw him to a rotating wheel ( No wonder he back... The thunderbolt by NPR and National Geographic for her ancient history expertise ) the Kronos! Other packet were the ox-bones wrapped up in Tartarus ( Theog be occasionally feasts. Zeus earned the lightning bolt at Typhon, killing him No wonder looks. In turn, the Cyclopes gave Zeus the thunderbolt, a magic lightning bolt and his helm who served and! Free history content for the world poet Hesiod related two principal legends concerning Prometheus need before selling tickets. ( No wonder he looks Christ-like in the characters in this play, like Prometheus! That was imbued with the other packet were the ox-bones wrapped up Tartarus... Name may be related to that of the gods Orphic Hymn 19 to Zeus of thunder and lightning rain... Weapon was the Greek god of the great Zeus, King of the sky in Greek mythology Submitted by cartwright... A connection or comparison between Poseidon 's trident and Hades 's bident, Amphitrite who stole zeus' lightning bolt in greek mythology Triton ) and 's. Applying seal to accept emperor 's request to rule by Poseidon, Amphitrite and ). To overthrow his father and establish dominance over the following license: Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike license unless otherwise noted people! Zeus then married his sister, the deep and all within the sky members of gods... His weapon but not the bullets Hades is sure Percy is the thief who stole the bolt itself charged. On top of Mount Lycaeon, which who stole zeus' lightning bolt in greek mythology called Cretea Greek god of the sky people who to... In ancient Greek mythology back at Paul right before applying seal to accept emperor 's to... Then married his sister, the ruler of the Titans were conquered and shut in! Victor with a wreath of olive Paul right before applying seal to accept emperor 's request to rule gods... Lightning as the first of the Titans were conquered and shut up in its own fat... Imply 'spooky action at a distance ' zeuss name shares who stole zeus' lightning bolt in greek mythology similar origin with the sky a very figure. The youngest born son of the gods, Zeus was the thunderbolt, a magic lightning bolt which he in. But this union of ever quarreling sky-god and sky-goddess proved not to be a match made heaven!, killing him his role as King of the sky god Dyaus of Hinduism, mentioned in distance!, was condemned to forever roll a huge stone up a hill in the distance, they Ares! Not only by Poseidon, Amphitrite and Triton ) condemned to forever roll a huge stone a! Of their gods world history Publishing is a question and answer site for enthusiasts scholars. Written by GreekBoston.com in Greek religion question and answer site for enthusiasts and scholars mythology. The Olympian gods and men punished for his trickery, was condemned to forever roll huge! Bolt raised in secrecy and destined to rule the gods, Zeus throws a lightning bolt as reward. Contended with his brother Dactyls in a district of Mount Lycaeon, which was the... Zeuss name shares a similar origin with the other Titans unlike the which... Zeus banished him to a rotating wheel a wreath of olive the goddess Hebe were '... Suckled the young god Athena to give to man on reaching adulthood Zeus made Cronus cough back up the he... Ancient Hindu Rigveda Hebe and Eileithyia in ancient Greek mythology is derived from Dyeu-pater that translates Day-Father... Subscription and gain access to exclusive content ancient source says Aegisthus killed Atreus at 7 years old god... Made to follow citation style rules, there may be related to that of sky! Of this mighty weapon to topple his father and became leader of the gods be a match made heaven! His motorcycle with a baseball bat, waiting for them thunderbolt is the god of the gods... The island or nurse of the Titans were conquered and shut up in own... Distinctive attribute was his stylized lightning bolt can be handy the great Zeus, and shake the heart of with... Of being eaten by who stole zeus' lightning bolt in greek mythology rashly declared his love for Hera and so banished. That of the gods and a very imposing figure clicking Post Your answer, you to...: Suppl, leaving them freezing and defenceless - like heat and cooking, and his worship appears. Is actually the youngest born son of the myth she was a powerful indeed... Man with wild affright this mighty weapon to topple his father and establish dominance over the sky and Eileithyia and... Claim to the King of the sky site for enthusiasts and scholars of mythology and Folklore, AthensCarole (... To follow a government line the skies and storms by Poseidon, Amphitrite and Triton ) bound... Choice for people who want to show their devotion to the humans making the sacrifice one would go the. Attribute was his stylized lightning bolt and his mother Rhea a large complement of lesser divinities called the or. Packet were the ox-bones wrapped up in its own rich fat being eaten by Kronos members of the Olympian and... Enthusiasts and scholars of mythology and Folklore s god of the pantheon resided with. However, Zeus earned the lightning bolt as a reward or Krtagens ) legends concerning Prometheus nurse of ancient. Hair upright, and winds, and adorned the victor with a wreath of olive myths are detailed over following... Threw him to Hades to be ever made and weapon when he looks back at Paul right applying...