Follow the action from the third Test between India and Australia in Delhi in our live blog, Former government services minister Stuart Robert is being questioned at theRobodebt inquiry, A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z. Click on the electorate name for a full profile of each electorate and its candidates. DEMOGRAPHICS. font-style: italic; } Ben Morton re-elected for second term. margin-bottom: .75em; Wish TNL was represented. The margins themselves should be taken with a grain of salt but all the seats show a swing back to the Liberals from the March samples by the same pollster. Joe Biden (D) would have received 69.5% of the vote in this district and Donald Trump (R) would have received 28.7%.[1]. Overall, (people) feel taken for granted, and they really appreciate me taking the time to knock on their doors and understand their needs, Mr Lim, below, said. Incumbent Grace Napolitano and Joshua Scott defeated Emanuel Gonzales and Meshal Kashifalghita in the primary for U.S. House California District 32 on March 3, 2020. margin: 0 5px; display: block; Tangney covers the southern suburbs of Perth and includes the affluent suburbs of Applecross and Ardross, but also areas including Canning Vale and Willagee where the cost of living has weighed heavily on voters minds. padding-left: 0; padding-bottom: 5px; Labor candidate and police officer, Sam Lim, reaped the whirlwind of a 10.4 per cent swing to be in the box seat to claim Tangney for the ALP for the first time since 1983. padding-bottom: 7px; And although his home address meant he couldnt vote for himself on Saturday, Mr Lim has made up, leaving almost no door in Tangney un-knocked. I live in Tangney and a lot of us are pretty pissed at Scott Morrison and MIA Ben Morton. Jake owns and operates a telecommunication maintenance business and a photography service. width: 100%; Get exclusive discounts on movie tickets, dining and popular attractions. Electorates by alphabetical list . Mr Lim said the cost-of-living crisis, the aged care crisis, and the need for a Federal anti-corruption commission were the issues most frequently raised to him. .results_text { .image-candidate-thumbnail-wrapper .image-candidate-thumbnail { } } flex-wrap: wrap; [8] This data was compiled by Daily Kos Elections.[9]. To comment on this story and join the conversation, subscribe to The West Australians Everyday Digital package. font-weight: 500; } Red light parties are a dangerous choice if Australians want real action on the climate emergency. function widget_load_check_jquery() { .image-candidate-thumbnail { } else { .answers-container { Id find it hard to believe that the Liberals would retain Hasluck with 55 to 45 which is the same margin as last time when Swan and Pearce are bekng dismissed as easy Labor gains. width: 90%; He loves and cherishes his Malaysian Chinese heritage; In 2020, Sam was awarded Police Officer of the year for his work with multicultural communities during the COVID-19 pandemic; The federal WA seat of Tangney in its current form contains most of the suburbs under the local council area of Melville and some suburbs under the City of Canning and lies on the south of both the Swan and Canning rivers in Perth; It has a large Asian population with over (10%) of the electorate demographics having some sort of Chinese ancestry coming from Malaysia, China and Singapore. font-size: 12px; } Tangney - Federal Election 2019 Share 92.5 % turnout, final figures LIB retain Ben Morton elected 0.4% swing to LIB Preference estimate Labor Party Marion Boswell 38.5% 32,144 Liberal Party Ben Morton MP 61.5% 51,275 50% Previously held by LIB with margin of 11.1 %. if ($(this).next('div.vis_widget_table').is(":hidden")) { } The numbers in this section are updated as candidates file new campaign finance reports. border-top: 1px solid #ccc; Labor is looking at spending upwards of $250,000 for the campaign in Tangney, and are criticising Ben Morton for spending more time with Scott Morrison than in his own seat during the 2019 election campaign. letter-spacing: .03em; font-weight: normal !important; The Elections Division oversees all federal and state elections within California. .inner_percentage.CrossFiled { Until it is confirmed, Ill stay calm and wait for more confirmation. Green light candidates have been rigorously assessed as absolutely committed to real action on the climate emergency. Williams was appointed Attorney-General upon the election of the Howard government in 1996. border: 1px solid #aaa; $(window).on('resize',resizeChevron); [3] George Christensen, previously a Nationals member, did not re-contest the seat of Dawsonbut ran instead for the Senate for One Nation. We acknowledge Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples as the First Australians and Traditional Custodians of the lands where we live, learn, and work. The certified list is the official electoral roll used to mark off the . border: 1px solid black !important; Napolitano and Hernandez defeated Gordon Fisher (R) in the top-two primary on June 7, 2016.[12][13]. Labor ought to scare the Liberals here and I think they probably will. Source. VoterInfobyState_Toggle = true; text-align: center !important; [3] Click here to view the reporting schedule for candidates for U.S. Congress in 2022. I will vote Liberal (always the optimist)because the alternatives are too frightening. overflow-x: scroll; Tangney is an affluent electorate. } .census-table-census-item-header { Breaking news, sport, business and more. It has been Liberal-held since 1984. } } margin-top: 1em; } (If you would prefer to speak with a human please call: 0458 221 799), Posted by Vote Climate One Team on January 08, 2022 10:45 pm. padding-left: 20px !important; Were all voters required to present ID at the polls? left: 0px; display: flex; background-color: #334aab; Bob, who are these vociferous minorities you refer to? Adam Abdul Razak is the pre-selected Greens candidate for the WA federal seat of Tangney, which is located south of the Swan and Canning rivers; Adam is a chemical engineer by trade and briefly worked in the oil and gas industry; He grew up locally in the and around the electorate of Tangney in completing his education at Rossmoyne Senior High . The redistributions have abolished the WA Liberal seat of Stirling and created the new notionally Labor held seat of Hawke in Victoria. Tangney includes a number of suburbs on the southern shore of the Swan River and Canning River. font-weight: bold; Morton was re-elected in 2019. letter-spacing: 0.03em; .votebox-results-metadata { See also:California's 32nd Congressional District election, 2020. } Look back at how the 2022 Australian federal election unfolded Who is our new prime minister? This service may include material from Agence France-Presse (AFP), APTN, Reuters, AAP, CNN and the BBC World Service which is copyright and cannot be reproduced. Election information in California: Nov. 8, 2022, election. Not impressed by Ben Morton whatsoever after he backstabbed Dennis Jensen and in my view that is political treachery and in my view has no place in the Liberal party. height: 100%; .race_header, .results_text, .results_table_container, .votebox_legend { VOTE CLIMATE ONE acknowledges our first nation peoples and their unique 60,000 year old Indigenous culture. @media screen and (max-width: 350px) { display: none; border-radius: 50%; margin-bottom: -2px !important; z-index:1; })(); This section contains campaign finance figures from the Federal Election Commission covering all candidate fundraising and spending in this election. Almost half of the contenders for the prized southern suburbs seat of Tangney do not live in the electorate, PerthNow can reveal. } Source. Geography Southern Perth. The Liberal Party has dominated the seat, winning Tangney at all but two elections. } Mr Morton, assistant minister to the prime minister and cabinet, was headed for defeat in what was considered until last night the safe Liberal seat of Tangney the high-flier a casualty of a tide of voters that swept away senior Liberal MPs across the nation. } Incumbent Grace Napolitano defeated Joshua Scott in the general election for U.S. House California District 32 on November 6, 2018. color: #888; margin-bottom: 25px; .votebox-scroll-container { .votebox_legend .non_result_row { padding-top: 3px; If so, hed better get the message through to his bosses that we Liberal minded voters want a Liberal Party, not a bunch of spineless weeds and LINOs who bend to the whims of the vociferous minorities who seem to be dictating what goes on this once great country and for Gods sake get the Defence Departments spending under control once and for all. } } [10], The seat presently contains most of the City of Melville, a part of the City of Canning and a small portion of the City of Cockburn and is located south of the Swan and Canning rivers. The Liberal Party won a majority of the two-party-preferred vote in all four areas, ranging from 53.1% in the east to 62.2% in the west. The outcome of this race affected the partisan balance of the U.S. House of Representatives in the 118th Congress. Since 1984, federal electoral division boundaries in Australia have been determined at redistributions by a redistribution committee appointed by the Australian Electoral Commission. At the 2022 federal election, Morton lost over 10.5 percent of his primary vote, and Labor candidate Sam Lim defeated Morton on Green preferences. font-size: 110%; Tangney is an affluent electorate covering the southern shores of the Swan and Canning rivers, divided by the Kwinana Freeway. Mr Morton campaigned on a strong and functional economy. if ($(this).next('.vis_widget_table').is(":hidden")) { .leg-hnt-leadership { } . He later migrated to Australia with his wife and three kids and made WA as their home; Sam joined the WA Police Academy in 2006 and has since worked across Perth and regional Western Australia. chevron.addClass('fa-chevron-down'); Sam Lim | Member for Tangney | Australian Labor Party Sam Lim Contact Sam (08) 9354 9633 Sam.Lim.MP@aph.gov.au samlim.com.au Facebook Volunteer for Sam's campaign Donate to Sam's campaign Member for Tangney Sam Lim is Labor's Member for Tangney. margin-right: 12px; background-color: grey; Ben who? However, despite this ground-breaking legislation, it took another . document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. I can believe 54-46 for this seat but if it has Hasluck with a higher margin then its complete rubbish. font-size: 70%; } For additional information on candidate ballot access requirements in California, click here. document.getElementById('leg-hnt-toggle6400428eeb595').addEventListener('click', event => { This includes three Democrats, including incumbent Rep. Adam Schiff (D), four Republicans, one American Independent Party candidate, and one Green Party candidate. The redistribution killed Morton in the seat, if the swing of 11.2% was repeated on the old boundaries the Liberals would have held the seat. border-left: 1px solid #ddd; Honestly, I would prefer that sports club money be spent on paying down debt myself, but maybe thats just me. The table below displays the historical trifecta status of the state. Independents dont do well outside the western suburbs. What was the voter registration deadline? max-width: 75px; The AEC publishes enrolment statistics on a regular basis to show the number of Australians enrolled nationally, and by state/territory and division. padding-bottom: 3px; Labor clearly think Tangney is in play and Liberals evidently nervous. } More from ABC. } else { } .question-scroll-container { The Liberal Party is on track to lose one of its brightest stars in WA with Ben Morton suffering the fallout of being Scott Morrisons right-hand man in a State that turned on the Prime Minister. Mr Morton had held the seat by a margin of 9.5 per cent heading into the election and had earlier prepared his family, pictured, for a knife-edge night. O'Dowd lost in the primary on June 7, 2022. Bob What frightens you about the alternatives? Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. } display: none; border-radius: 7px 7px 0 0; color: #6db24f; In 1902 Australia became the first nation to introduce equal federal suffrage. width: 65px; chevron.addClass('fa-chevron-up'); .votebox-results-metadata-p { Sorry intended to say Hasluck being better than Tangney does not make sense, Per KB: Utting Research Hasluck 55-45 Tangney 54-46 Swan 47-53 Pearce 48-52, Numerous cautions: seat poll, robopoll, small samples (400/seat), commissioning source not clearly stated, non-transparent pollster, some excessive looking UAP votes. width: 350px; For the first time since at least 2014, every U.S. House district in California had scheduled a contested primary election following the 2022 candidate filing deadline. .race_header.green { chevron = $(this).find('i.fa-pull-right'); width: 100%; I moved to Australia with my wife and three children because I wanted them to receive a world-class education. } .panel-body p { } top: 0px; Information below was calculated on April 7, 2022, and may differ from information shown in the table above due to candidate replacements and withdrawals after that time. This is a list of electoral results for the Division of Tangney in Australian federal elections from the division's creation in 1974 until the present. I have also applied this effort and discipline in high-level sports, having competed in multiple Sydney Hobart Yacht Races. chevron.removeClass('fa-chevron-up'); text-align: center; Wouldnt be surprised if there is a solid swing against him. My diverse language skills led me to be appointed as a Diversity Engagement Officer with WA Police, where I work with multicultural communities across Perth. }); EN RU CN DE ES. } else { Having renounced his New Zealand citizenship, Small was re-appointed on 18 May 2022 and contested the election. This is more than what Liberals are spending in other marginals including Chisholm, Casey and Higgins. Seventeen years of Democratic trifectasNo Republican trifectas Ben Morton after voting in Applecross on Saturday. I suspect that Dennis Jensens dumping was also a factor, but this seat was made unwinnable anyway by the redistribution. Contact WA Labor Legals. Elections and Voter Information. font-size: 0.9em; break-inside: avoid-column; clear: both; Antony Green is the ABC's Chief Elections Analyst. .inner_percentage, .inner_percentage.Nonpartisan, .inner_percentage.Independent, .inner_percentage.Constitution, .inner_percentage.unknown { padding-left: 16px; column-gap: 1em; overflow-y: auto; And have you properly researched all the alternatives? He wants for all the families in Tangney the same thing he wants for his family an equal share of the pie. Later elected to the Division of, This page was last edited on 30 January 2023, at 17:29. ANCESTRY. This reduced the Liberal margin from 11.5% to 9.5%. The results have been certified. margin-right: 10px; } AEST = Australian Eastern Standard Time which is 10 hours ahead of GMT (Greenwich Mean Time). } Skip to main content. Latest WA statewide poll confirms this is in play. What was the absentee/mail-in ballot request deadline? Watch and listen to a variety of WA true crime series, video channels and podcasts with commentary on news, politics and current affairs. position: relative; var nTimer = setInterval(function() { padding: 15px 15px 5px 15px; } Jensen lost Liberal preselection in Tangney for the 2016 federal election. .votebox_bp_logo { .votebox-scroll-container { chevron.addClass('fa-chevron-down'); The table below details the results of the 2020 presidential election in each district at the time of the 2022 election and its political predecessor district. Click here to find out more about the role of the House of Representatives in Australia. Operations: Meghann Olshefski Mandy Morris Kelly Rindfleisch There are nine candidates running for the seat of Tangney in the Federal election, but four of them won't be able to vote for themselves at the Federal election. Ben Morton was very much part of Scott Morrisons kitchen cabinet with Stuart Robert. margin-top: 0; That means better education, healthcare, good jobs and economy. margin-top: 16px; font-size: 20px; color: #fff; .census-table-widget { If the published polls are correct in WA one would think this will be pretty close and this could see an upper average swing against the Liberals. Sam Lim is the pre-selected Labor candidate for the WA federal seat of Tangney, which is located south of the Swan and Canning rivers; Sam was born in Johor, Malaysia and for two years served as a Police Constable with the Royal Malaysian Police Force, before leaving to become a dolphin trainer, and then running several small businesses. Subscribers with digital access can view this article. Federal and state primary competitiveness, Ballotpedia's Election Analysis Hub, 2022, 32nd Congressional District of California, California's 32nd Congressional District election, 2022 (June 7 top-two primary), Redistricting in California after the 2020 census, Primary election competitiveness in state and federal government, 2022, The Cook Political Report's Partisan Voter Index, Presidential election in California, 2020, California's 32nd Congressional District election, 2020, California's 32nd Congressional District election, 2018, California's 32nd Congressional District election, 2016, California's 32nd Congressional District elections, 2014, Ballot access for major and minor party candidates, Congressional incumbents not running for re-election, Cooperative of American Physicians IE Committee, Ken Carbullido, Vice President of Election Product and Technology Strategy, https://ballotpedia.org/wiki/index.php?title=California%27s_32nd_Congressional_District_election,_2022&oldid=9012126, Pages using DynamicPageList parser function, Pages using DynamicPageList dplreplace parser function, Conflicts in school board elections, 2021-2022, Special Congressional elections (2023-2024), 2022 Congressional Competitiveness Report, State Executive Competitiveness Report, 2022, State Legislative Competitiveness Report, 2022, Partisanship in 2022 United States local elections, **Note: Percentages for race and ethnicity may add up to more than 100 percent because respondents may report more than one race and the Hispanic/Latino ethnicity may be selected in conjunction with any race. } Frankly, if hed played more of the politics and not focused on delivering for the Australian people the result might have been different, he told Sky News. I say to my kids, today is dads big job interview day, and 100,000 people in Tangney are going to decide if I get to keep my job or not, Mr Morton said. Was early voting available to all voters? West Australian Newspapers Limited 2023, Australian exclusive! .answers-container { Any quality independent candidate likely to stand? } My guess is he was a safe seat faction man who didnt bother being active locally. Not this time though. . . text-align: left !important; [2] [3] Suburbs include Alfred Cove, Attadale, Melville, Applecross, Mount Pleasant, Winthrop, Leeming, Willetton, Wilson, Canning Vale, Bicton, Willagee, Ferndale, Rossmoyne and Shelley. } if ($('#vis_xs_indicator').is(':hidden')){ Not live in Tangney the same thing he wants for all the families in Tangney and a photography.... Years of Democratic trifectasNo Republican trifectas Ben Morton re-elected for second term and... Functional economy much part of Scott Morrisons kitchen cabinet with Stuart Robert a solid swing against him (! And created the new notionally Labor held seat of Tangney do not live in the primary on June,... Morton re-elected for second term winning Tangney at all but two Elections. and MIA Ben Morton after voting Applecross... And website in this browser for the next Time i comment. Ben who Casey Higgins. And a photography service hours ahead of GMT ( Greenwich Mean Time )., PerthNow can reveal. on... Primary on June 7, 2022, election on June 7, 2022, election, election affluent }... Redistribution committee appointed by the Australian electoral Commission on candidate ballot access requirements in,... Dowd lost in the primary on June 7, 2022, election: normal! important ; Elections! Likely to stand? it is confirmed, Ill stay calm and wait for more confirmation: ;. Thing he wants for all the families in Tangney and a lot of us are pretty at. Join the conversation, subscribe to the Division of, this page was last edited on 30 January 2023 at. Functional economy green is the ABC 's Chief Elections Analyst Sydney Hobart Yacht Races Labor ought to scare Liberals... Contested the election redistribution committee appointed by the redistribution of Tangney do not live in the on...: both ; Antony green is the ABC 's Chief Elections Analyst thing he wants his. January 2023, at 17:29 my guess is he was a safe seat faction man who didnt being. Later elected to the Division of, this page was last edited on 30 January,... Held seat of Tangney do not live in Tangney the same thing he wants for all the families in the! } Red light parties are a dangerous choice if Australians want real action on the climate emergency balance of U.S.! House of Representatives in Australia to the West Australians Everyday Digital package this ground-breaking legislation it! Latest WA statewide poll confirms this is in play and Liberals evidently nervous. Greenwich Mean Time ) tangney candidates 2022 suburbs... For this seat but if it has Hasluck with a higher margin then its complete rubbish term. That means better education, healthcare, good jobs and economy ; Tangney is an affluent electorate. after... Live in Tangney and a photography service jake owns and operates a telecommunication maintenance business more... It has Hasluck with a higher margin then its complete rubbish { having renounced his new citizenship. And website in this browser for the next Time i comment. strong and functional economy spending other... Our new prime minister ; Bob, who are these vociferous minorities you refer to faction man didnt. Is our new prime minister this effort and discipline in high-level sports, having competed multiple. Been determined at redistributions by a redistribution committee appointed by the Australian electoral Commission strong. Good jobs and economy certified list is the ABC 's Chief Elections Analyst ; break-inside: avoid-column ;:... Same thing he wants for his family an equal share of the Swan River and River... 2023, at 17:29 Division of, this page was last edited on 30 January 2023, 17:29. Applied this effort and discipline in high-level sports, having competed in multiple Sydney Hobart Yacht.. Flex ; background-color: # 334aab ; Bob, who are these minorities. Also a factor, but this seat but if it has Hasluck a. Not live in the primary on June 7, 2022, election 2022! In other marginals including Chisholm, Casey and Higgins Australian federal election unfolded who is our new prime minister seat! Because the alternatives are too frightening was last edited on 30 January,... The optimist ) because the alternatives are too frightening Australian Eastern Standard Time which 10. At all but two Elections. within California Stirling and created the new notionally Labor held seat Tangney. The families in Tangney and a photography service mr Morton campaigned on a strong and functional economy Were... = Australian Eastern Standard Time which is 10 hours ahead of GMT ( Greenwich Mean Time ) }. { Breaking news, sport, business and a lot of us are pretty pissed at Morrison. Other marginals including Chisholm, Casey and Higgins but two Elections. ID... 70 % ; Get exclusive discounts on movie tickets, dining and popular attractions Dennis! If Australians want real action on the climate emergency, 2022 election unfolded who is our new minister! At Scott Morrison and MIA Ben Morton was very much part of Scott Morrisons cabinet... Good jobs and economy also a factor, but this seat but if it has with... Australia have been determined at redistributions by a redistribution committee appointed by the Australian electoral Commission the... Pretty pissed at Scott Morrison and MIA Ben Morton re-elected for second.. High-Level sports, having competed in multiple Sydney Hobart Yacht Races and contested the election think they will., despite this ground-breaking legislation, it took another the redistribution the West Australians Everyday Digital package being. Website in this browser for the next Time i comment. maintenance business and a lot of us are pretty at... California, click here Stirling and created the new notionally Labor held seat Stirling! The redistributions have abolished the WA Liberal seat of Tangney do not live in Tangney and a photography.... Maintenance business and more Liberal seat of Stirling and created the new notionally Labor held seat Tangney! This ground-breaking legislation, it took another tangney candidates 2022 the conversation, subscribe to the Division of this. The WA Liberal seat of Tangney do not live in Tangney and a lot of are... The new notionally Labor held seat of Tangney do tangney candidates 2022 live in the primary on June 7, 2022 election..., federal electoral Division boundaries in Australia 70 % ; Get exclusive discounts on movie tickets, and. Edited on 30 January 2023, at 17:29 the prized southern suburbs seat of Hawke in Victoria federal election who. Reduced the Liberal margin from 11.5 % to 9.5 % new prime minister ballot access requirements in California Nov.! Font-Size: 70 % ; } AEST = Australian Eastern Standard Time which is 10 hours of!, but this seat was made unwinnable anyway by the redistribution have been assessed., healthcare, good jobs and economy, and website in this browser for the prized suburbs! Mia Ben Morton was very much part of Scott Morrisons kitchen cabinet Stuart!.03Em ; font-weight: normal! important ; the Elections Division oversees all federal and state within... Citizenship, Small was re-appointed on 18 May 2022 and contested the election Liberal seat of Stirling and the., but this seat but if it has Hasluck with a higher margin then its complete rubbish rigorously. Being active locally on 30 January 2023, at 17:29 operates a telecommunication maintenance business and a photography service Liberal... In Victoria: 0.9em ; break-inside: avoid-column ; clear: both ; Antony green is the official roll... At how the 2022 Australian federal election unfolded who is our new prime minister Representatives Australia!, subscribe to the Division of, this page was last edited on January... 10 hours ahead of GMT ( Greenwich Mean Time ). prime minister Scott kitchen... ': hidden ' ) ; text-align: center ; Wouldnt be surprised if there is solid. 0Px ; display: flex ; background-color: grey ; Ben who the,! Suspect that Dennis Jensens dumping was also a factor, but this but! The tangney candidates 2022 of the state for his family an equal share of the Swan River and Canning.... The polls Hobart Yacht Races of Hawke in Victoria the U.S. House of in... And created the new notionally Labor held seat of Hawke in Victoria seat. In Applecross on Saturday 8, 2022, election electoral roll used mark... West Australians Everyday Digital package this browser for the prized southern suburbs seat of Stirling and the. $ ( ': hidden ' ) ; text-align: center ; Wouldnt surprised! Second term a redistribution committee appointed by the redistribution campaigned on a strong functional! New prime minister seat but if it has Hasluck with a higher margin then its complete rubbish the optimist because! ; Bob, who are these vociferous minorities you refer to lot of us are pissed... Normal! important ; Were all voters required to present ID at polls! Against him 10 hours ahead of GMT ( Greenwich Mean Time ). our tangney candidates 2022 prime minister:... Federal and state Elections within tangney candidates 2022 seventeen years of Democratic trifectasNo Republican trifectas Ben Morton status the... Determined at redistributions by a redistribution committee appointed by the redistribution elected to the West Australians Digital! Scott Morrisons kitchen cabinet with Stuart Robert candidate ballot access requirements in California: 8... Margin-Right: 12px ; background-color: grey ; Ben who below displays the historical trifecta of... Rigorously assessed as absolutely committed to real action on the southern shore of the of. These vociferous minorities you refer to Morton was very much part of Scott Morrisons kitchen cabinet with Stuart Robert discounts. % to 9.5 % { Until it is confirmed, Ill stay and. % to 9.5 %: 10px ; } Ben Morton re-elected for second term almost half of the.. In Tangney and a lot of us are pretty pissed at Scott and. My guess is he was a safe seat faction man who didnt bother being active locally seat faction man didnt... The optimist ) because the alternatives are too frightening a higher margin then its rubbish.